According to Duane Buziak, an FHA vs conventional loan calculator is only as useful as the numbers you feed it. Most homebuyers type in a price and a rate and stop there, which leaves out the two inputs that decide this comparison: mortgage insurance and how long you’ll keep the loan. At Mortgage Rate Hawk, the philosophy is “We Don’t Just Look. We Hunt.” Watch. Compare. Save. That means chasing down the real figures behind each program before trusting any result on a screen. The seven strategies below walk through how to do that, so the monthly and long-term cost difference you see is one you can plan around. Where the article uses dollar figures, they are labeled illustrations, not quotes.
1. Start with rates quoted for your actual credit profile
Calculators often pre-fill a national average rate, and advertised rates usually assume a score of 740 or higher with a sizable down payment. FHA and conventional pricing react to credit differently. Conventional pricing and mortgage insurance tighten sharply as scores fall, while FHA pricing is flatter across score tiers. That is why a generic rate can flip the answer.
Illustration: a buyer with a 660 score plugs advertised averages into a calculator and sees conventional looking far more expensive. After collecting written quotes for both programs, the real rate gap turns out to be much narrower than the averages implied, and the comparison depends on the insurance numbers instead. The input changed the conclusion.
- Request a free no-touch credit check so your score is known without a hard inquiry.
- Ask for FHA and conventional quotes on the same day, with the same lock period and the same points or credits.
- Enter the exact rate, points, and APR for each program into the calculator.
- Re-run the numbers if you get quotes from other sources, such as Rocket or Lower, so every figure shares a date and a lock term.
Lower’s digital application and pricing transparency are real strengths, which makes it a useful quote to bring into a comparison. Duane Buziak also has direct access to PowerTPO, the wholesale subsidiary of Lower LLC, along with hundreds of other wholesale lenders, so one conversation can price both programs without a retail markup. No lender is promised a lower rate; the point is having comparable quotes.
The common mistake is using a national average or a teaser rate built for a 740+ score. Measure the quoted rate and APR for each program, compared on the same date. If the dates or lock periods differ, the comparison is noise.
2. Model the down payment side by side
Down payment rules differ by program, and mixing them up is how people end up crediting a loan type for what is really a cash decision. As of 2026, HUD sets FHA’s minimum at 3.5% down with a 580 score or higher, and 10% for scores of 500 to 579. Conventional loans can go to 3% down through programs such as Fannie Mae’s HomeReady, with eligibility rules attached. Conventional loans do not require 20% down; that threshold only removes mortgage insurance.
Illustration on a $350,000 home, assuming closing costs and prepaids total $10,500:
- FHA at 3.5% down: $12,250 down, base loan $337,750, cash to close $22,750.
- Conventional at 3% down: $10,500 down, loan $339,500, cash to close $21,000.
- 10% down on both: $35,000 down, cash to close $45,500. The FHA base loan is $315,000 and the conventional loan is $315,000.
The minimum-down scenarios show what each program asks of you. The equal-10% scenario isolates what the program itself changes, mainly insurance and rate. Run all three in the calculator, then add your estimated closing costs and prepaids so the output is cash to close, not just down payment.
The pitfall is comparing FHA at 3.5% down against conventional at 20% down, then crediting FHA or conventional for a difference that is really about equity. Measure cash to close and loan amount in each scenario, and note any seller credits you are assuming.
3. Capture FHA mortgage insurance correctly (UFMIP and annual MIP)
FHA loans carry two charges. The upfront mortgage insurance premium (UFMIP) is 1.75% of the base loan amount and is usually financed into the balance. The annual mortgage insurance premium (MIP) is billed monthly. Many calculators fold in only one, or neither.
Illustration: on a $340,000 base FHA loan, UFMIP is $5,950. Financed at an assumed 6.25% over 30 years, that adds about $36.64 to the monthly principal and interest and raises the balance you pay interest on for the life of the loan. It is a cost you never write a check for, which is why it gets forgotten.
- Check HUD’s current MIP schedule on HUD.gov and confirm the rate for your loan amount and loan-to-value (LTV) ratio. LTV is the loan balance divided by the home’s value.
- Enter UFMIP as financed, not paid in cash, unless you plan to pay it upfront.
- Enter annual MIP as a monthly cost: base loan times the annual rate, divided by 12.
- Set the duration. As of 2026, FHA loans with less than 10% down generally carry MIP for the life of the loan, while 10% or more down generally lets it end after 11 years.
The common mistake is assuming FHA MIP falls off at 20% equity the way conventional PMI does. It does not. Measure the total monthly payment including MIP, and the loan balance after UFMIP is financed. If the calculator does not show both, add them by hand.
4. Model conventional PMI as a variable, not a flat number
Private mortgage insurance (PMI) on a conventional loan is priced from your credit score and LTV. A calculator default, often a flat 0.5% to 1%, can be wrong in either direction. On the same loan, a buyer with a 760 score and a buyer with a 680 score can see PMI that differs by a factor of two or three.
Illustration, not a quote: on a $330,000 loan at about 95% LTV, a PMI rate of 1.0% costs $275 a month, while 0.35% costs about $96. That difference alone can decide whether conventional beats FHA at your score. The FHA premium barely moves with credit, so a higher score shifts the break-even toward conventional.
Then model when PMI ends. Under the Homeowners Protection Act, you can request removal when the balance reaches 80% of the original value, and servicers must terminate it automatically at 78% on schedule, as the CFPB explains.
- Get a PMI quote based on your score and planned down payment.
- Enter it as a monthly dollar amount.
- In the long-term comparison, drop it at 80% LTV.
The mistakes are accepting the default percentage and treating PMI as permanent. Measure the monthly PMI amount and the month your LTV reaches 80%. A calculator that cannot show PMI ending will overstate conventional’s cost.
5. Run the break-even timeline
The break-even is the point at which one program’s cumulative cost overtakes the other’s. Looking at only the first payment hides it. Compare total cost at 5, 7, and 10 years, matched to how long you expect to keep the loan.
A worked illustration at a 660 score
This is an illustration with assumed rates, not a quote. Take a $350,000 purchase with a 660 score, in any of the states Duane Buziak is licensed in (VA, FL, TN, GA, DC, NC, SC, MD).
- FHA: 3.5% down ($12,250), base loan $337,750, plus UFMIP of $5,910.63, financed. Total loan $343,660.63 at an assumed 6.25%. Principal and interest: $2,115.98. Annual MIP at an assumed 0.55% on the base loan: about $154.80 a month. Total: about $2,271 a month.
- Conventional at 3% down: $10,500 down, loan $339,500 at an assumed 6.75%. Principal and interest: $2,202.00. PMI at an assumed 1.40%: about $396.08 a month. Total: about $2,598 a month.
Cumulative payments (principal, interest, and insurance, using flat monthly insurance for simplicity):
- 5 years: FHA $136,247 versus conventional $155,885, a $19,638 gap.
- 7 years: FHA $190,746 versus conventional $218,239, a $27,493 gap.
- 10 years: FHA $272,494 versus conventional $311,770, a $39,276 gap.
In this scenario, the conventional PMI would take about 136 months to reach 80% LTV on schedule. After it drops, conventional’s payment is roughly $69 a month below FHA’s, which would take decades to recover a gap this size. Balances after 10 years are close to equal, at roughly $289,500 on each loan. At these inputs, FHA wins for the horizon. With a 760 score and a lower PMI, the lines would cross.
Build your own table of principal, interest, insurance, and upfront costs at each year mark. The mistake is choosing on the lowest first-year payment without checking how long you will stay. Measure the total cost difference at 5, 7, and 10 years, and the crossover month if there is one.
6. Plan the refinance exit from FHA mortgage insurance
FHA MIP that lasts the life of the loan is the biggest long-term drag in the comparison. One way out is refinancing into a conventional loan once your equity is high enough to avoid PMI, or to carry only a small amount. The calculator should model that exit, not just the original loan.
Illustration: an FHA borrower reaching 20% equity in year five runs a refinance at three rate levels: lower, flat, and higher than today. At the lower rate, monthly savings are large and closing costs are recovered quickly. At a flat rate, savings come only from dropping MIP, so break-even takes longer. At a higher rate, the refinance may not pay at all.
- Estimate your home value and loan balance in year five. Be conservative on value.
- Run refinance scenarios at several rates, including today’s.
- Add realistic closing costs, including any no-out-of-pocket structure that raises the rate.
- Divide total closing costs by monthly savings. That is your break-even in months.
- Compare that number to how long you plan to stay in the home.
The common mistake is treating the refinance as guaranteed. Rates may be flat or higher, values may stall, and a conventional cash-out refinance is capped at a maximum of 90% LTV. Measure the break-even months and the monthly savings after refinance. An FHA loan that depends on a future refinance to make sense should be run at the no-refinance numbers first.
7. Stress-test qualification: DTI, loan limits, and property taxes
A comparison is meaningless if you do not qualify for the loan in it. Debt-to-income (DTI) ratio is your monthly debts divided by gross monthly income. The front-end ratio covers housing only. The back-end ratio adds car payments, student loans, and cards. FHA generally allows higher ratios than conventional with automated approval, which is one reason some buyers qualify for one and not the other.
Illustration: a buyer earning $7,000 a month has a $2,600 housing payment and $700 in other debts. That is a 37.1% front-end and a 47.1% back-end ratio. This can work under FHA automated underwriting, but it sits near the ceiling for conventional, and a $150 jump in insurance or taxes could tip it over. Placeholder tax and insurance figures hide exactly this.
The table below shows how the programs differ on the points a calculator needs. Treat the figures as 2026 guidelines to confirm at the time of your quote.
| Feature | FHA | Conventional (3% down) | Conventional (10% to 20% down) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Minimum down payment | 3.5% at 580+; 10% at 500 to 579 | 3% on eligible programs | 10% to 20% |
| Typical minimum score | 580 for 3.5% down | Generally 620 | Generally 620 |
| Upfront insurance | 1.75% UFMIP, usually financed | None | None |
| Monthly insurance | Annual MIP, set by loan size and LTV | PMI, priced by score and LTV | PMI, lower or none at 20% down |
| When insurance ends | 11 years with 10%+ down; life of loan under 10% down | Request at 80% LTV; automatic at 78% | Same rules, reached sooner |
| DTI flexibility | Higher ratios possible with automated approval | Lower ceiling with automated approval | Lower ceiling with automated approval |
| Credit sensitivity of cost | Lower | High | High |
| Cash-out limit | Program rules apply | Not applicable to purchase | Maximum 90% LTV on cash-out refinance |
Then check the loan limit. As of 2026, the FHFA conforming baseline is $832,750 for one-unit properties, with higher limits in designated high-cost counties. HUD sets separate FHA limits by county. Look yours up on both sites.
- Enter actual taxes, homeowners insurance, and any HOA dues for the specific property.
- Calculate front-end and back-end DTI for each program.
- Compare your loan amount to the 2026 limit for your county.
The mistake is placeholder tax and insurance figures that understate the payment. Measure your back-end DTI against each program’s guideline and your loan amount against the county limit.
Ten questions homebuyers ask about FHA, conventional, and the calculator
Is FHA or conventional cheaper for a $350,000 home with a 660 credit score?
FHA is often cheaper monthly at a 660 score, because conventional PMI rises sharply as scores fall. In the illustration above, FHA came to about $2,271 a month against about $2,598 for conventional at 3% down. Real quotes can change that, so rely on your own written rates.
Is FHA always cheaper than conventional each month?
No. With a higher score and a larger down payment, conventional PMI can fall low enough to beat FHA’s mortgage insurance. The gap often reverses around the mid-700s credit range with 5% to 10% down, though this varies by quote.
What is the minimum down payment for an FHA loan in 2026?
The minimum is 3.5% with a credit score of 580 or higher, and 10% for scores of 500 to 579, per HUD. Lender overlays can set a higher score floor.
Does a conventional loan require 20% down?
No. Programs such as Fannie Mae’s HomeReady allow 3% down for eligible borrowers. Putting 20% down removes PMI but is not a requirement.
What is UFMIP?
UFMIP is the upfront mortgage insurance premium on an FHA loan, currently 1.75% of the base loan amount. Most borrowers finance it into the balance instead of paying cash at closing.
Does FHA mortgage insurance ever go away?
Yes, but only under certain conditions. With 10% or more down, annual MIP generally ends after 11 years. With less than 10% down, it lasts for the life of the loan, so refinancing is the usual exit.
When can I remove PMI on a conventional loan?
You can request removal when the balance reaches 80% of the original home value, and servicers must end it automatically at 78% on schedule, as described by the CFPB. Good payment history is required.
Why do FHA vs conventional calculators give different answers?
Calculators use different default rates, PMI percentages, and assumptions about mortgage insurance duration. Entering your own quoted rates and insurance costs removes most of the difference.
What are the 2026 loan limits?
The FHFA conforming baseline for a one-unit home is $832,750 as of 2026, higher in some counties. FHA limits vary by county and are published by HUD, so check yours before you finalize a scenario.
How does Duane Buziak help compare the two loans?
Duane Buziak at Mortgage Rate Hawk runs FHA and conventional quotes side by side on the same day, using a free no-touch credit check and the same lock terms. He is licensed in VA, FL, TN, GA, DC, NC, SC, and MD and returns calls the same day.
Where Duane Buziak would start, and how to get both loans run side by side
Start with strategy 1, real quotes, then strategies 3 and 4, the accurate insurance inputs. Those three fix the biggest calculator errors, and everything else builds on them. After that, run the break-even timeline and the refinance model, and finish with the DTI and loan-limit check so you know the answer is one you can close on.
You can also skip the spreadsheet work. Duane Buziak at Mortgage Rate Hawk will run both programs side by side for you, with a same-day callback. Your dream home is waiting, so don’t let the mortgage process hold you back. Get your free rate comparison and personalized loan match today, with same-day expert guidance to help you find the right path forward, whether you’re a first-time buyer or ready to refinance.

One Response